Screenshotly vs ScreenshotOne
Compare Screenshotly and ScreenshotOne on list price, what counts toward quota, overage, output formats, and the capture features each one includes.
Screenshotly vs ScreenshotOne: At a Glance
At list price, Screenshotly includes more captures per dollar on every paid tier. ScreenshotOne offers more output formats, longer video, opt-in overage, and cached responses that do not count toward quota. Screenshotly adds AI element removal and device mockups on Growth and Scale.
Feature Comparison: Screenshotly vs ScreenshotOne
| Feature | Screenshotly | ScreenshotOne |
|---|---|---|
| Pricing | From $14/mo | From $17/mo for 2,000 screenshots (checked Nov 13, 2026) |
| Free allowance | 100 captures (lifetime) | 100 screenshots per month |
| Entry plan | $14 for 2,500 / month | $17 for 2,000 / month |
| Mid plan | $59 for 12,000 / month | $79 for 10,000 / month |
| Top self-serve plan | $199 for 50,000 / month | $259 for 50,000 / month |
| Requests per minute (paid tiers) | 40 / 80 / 200 | 40 / 80 / 150 |
| Over quota | Requests stop (429); no overage | Stops, or opt-in overage up to a hard limit |
| Cached responses count toward quota | Yes | No |
| Image and document formats | PNG, JPEG, WebP; PDF and HTML on Basic+ | PNG, JPEG, WebP, GIF, AVIF, PDF, HTML, Markdown and more |
| Video | WebM, 1–15 s (Scale) | MP4, MOV, AVI, WebM, GIF; up to 30 s (Growth+) |
| Cookie-banner handling | blockAds on all plans; AI removal on Growth+ | block_cookie_banners on all plans |
| AI element removal | ✅ Growth+ | ❌ Not documented |
| Device mockup frames | ✅ 6 templates (Growth+) | ❌ Not documented |
| Bulk requests | Up to 20 per batch (Growth+) | Up to 20 per bulk request |
Why Choose Screenshotly?
Where ScreenshotOne Stands Out
ScreenshotOne Limitations
When to Choose Which
Choose Screenshotly if…
- You want the most included captures at each list price
- You need consent banners, chat widgets, and overlays removed without maintaining selectors
- You want screenshots placed in browser, phone, tablet, or laptop frames by the API
- You prefer a fixed monthly bill with no possibility of overage charges
Choose ScreenshotOne if…
ScreenshotOne is the better fit if you need formats Screenshotly does not produce (GIF, AVIF, Markdown), videos longer than 15 seconds or in MP4, or webhooks and S3 upload on its lowest plan. It is also the better fit if your workload repeats identical requests and you want cache hits excluded from quota.
Screenshotly vs ScreenshotOne: The Verdict
For image and PDF capture of public pages, Screenshotly costs less per included capture and adds AI cleanup and mockups on Growth and Scale. ScreenshotOne covers more output formats and video, excludes cached responses from quota, and lets you opt into capped overage. Choose on the formats and billing behaviour you need, then confirm current prices on both sites.
Deep Dive: What This Trade-off Actually Looks Like
Both are hosted screenshot APIs with similar core options: viewport, full page, element capture, waits, ad and cookie-banner blocking, custom scripts, headers, cookies, caching, webhooks, and bulk requests of up to 20. The practical differences are price per included capture, what counts toward quota, and which outputs you need.
On price, Screenshotly's tiers include more captures: 2,500 for $14, 12,000 for $59, and 50,000 for $199, against ScreenshotOne's 2,000 for $17, 10,000 for $79, and 50,000 for $259 (list prices checked 13 November 2026). On counting, ScreenshotOne does not count responses served from its cache, while Screenshotly counts every successful capture, including cache hits. If most of your requests repeat identical options, factor that in.
On output, ScreenshotOne produces more formats (including GIF, AVIF, and Markdown) and longer video (up to 30 seconds, in MP4 and other containers, on its Growth and Scale plans). Screenshotly produces PNG, JPEG, and WebP on every plan, PDF and HTML on Basic and above, and WebM video of 1–15 seconds on Scale. Screenshotly's distinctive features are AI element removal and device mockup frames on Growth and above.
List Price by Monthly Volume
Monthly list prices checked on 13 November 2026, before any annual discount. ScreenshotOne overage applies only if you enable it. Cached ScreenshotOne responses do not count toward its quota.
| Monthly volume | Screenshotly | ScreenshotOne | What decides it |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2,000 / month | $14 (Basic, 2,500 included) | $17 (Basic, 2,000 included) | Screenshotly $3 lower |
| 10,000 / month | $59 (Growth, 12,000 included) | $79 (Growth, 10,000 included) | Screenshotly $20 lower |
| 12,000 / month | $59 (Growth) | $91 ($79 + 2,000 × $0.006 overage, if enabled) | Screenshotly $32 lower |
| 50,000 / month | $199 (Scale) | $259 (Scale) | Screenshotly $60 lower |
Migration Walkthrough
Most ScreenshotOne options have a direct Screenshotly field. Screenshotly takes a JSON POST body and an x-api-key header.
- 1
Map the request options
viewport_width/viewport_height → width/height; full_page → fullPage; format → format; image_quality → quality; wait_for_selector → waitForSelector; wait_until: networkidle0 → waitForNetworkIdle: true; selector → selector; device_scale_factor → deviceScaleFactor (1–3); dark_mode → darkMode; block_ads → blockAds; hide_selectors → hideSelectors (Growth+); scripts → javascript (Growth+); headers and cookies → headers and cookies (Basic+); user_agent → userAgent; time_zone → timezone; cache/cache_ttl → cache/cacheTtl (Basic+, 60–86,400 s).
- 2
Convert units and defaults
ScreenshotOne delay is in seconds; Screenshotly delay is in milliseconds (max 10,000). ScreenshotOne defaults to JPEG; Screenshotly defaults to PNG. Screenshotly waits for DOMContentLoaded unless you set waitForNetworkIdle.
const res = await fetch('https://screenshotly.app/api/screenshot', { method: 'POST', headers: { 'x-api-key': process.env.SCREENSHOTLY_API_KEY, 'content-type': 'application/json' }, body: JSON.stringify({ url: 'https://example.com', width: 1280, height: 1024, fullPage: true, format: 'jpeg', quality: 80, delay: 2000, blockAds: true, }), }); - 3
Check plan gates
PDF, HTML, headers, cookies, caching, and webhooks need Basic or higher. Custom JavaScript, selector hiding, AI removal, mockups, and batch jobs need Growth or higher. Requests that use a higher-tier feature return 403 naming the plan required.
When ScreenshotOne is actually the right call
Every tool has legitimate fits. Be honest with yourself — if any of these apply, stay with ScreenshotOne.
- You need GIF, AVIF, Markdown, or other formats Screenshotly does not produce.
- You need video longer than 15 seconds, or in MP4, on a mid-tier plan.
- Your workload repeats identical requests and you want cache hits excluded from quota.
- You want the option of capped overage instead of requests stopping at the quota.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Screenshotly cheaper than ScreenshotOne?
At list price on November 13, 2026, yes at each comparable tier: $14 for 2,500 captures vs $17 for 2,000, $59 for 12,000 vs $79 for 10,000, and $199 vs $259 for 50,000. If many of your requests repeat and would be served from ScreenshotOne’s cache, its effective cost can be lower, because cached responses do not count there and do count on Screenshotly.
What happens when I exceed my quota on each service?
Screenshotly returns 429 at your plan quota or your own lower hard limit and never bills overage. ScreenshotOne charges overage only if you enable it, at $0.009, $0.006, or $0.004 per extra screenshot depending on the plan, capped by a monthly hard limit.
Do both services block cookie banners?
Yes. ScreenshotOne has a block_cookie_banners option. Screenshotly’s blockAds option (all plans) blocks ad requests and hides common consent-banner selectors, and AI element removal (Growth+) detects and removes cookie banners, newsletter popups, chat widgets, social overlays, and ads.
How hard is it to switch from ScreenshotOne?
Most options map one-to-one: viewport_width and viewport_height become width and height, full_page becomes fullPage, wait_for_selector becomes waitForSelector, and block_ads becomes blockAds. Note that ScreenshotOne’s delay is in seconds while Screenshotly’s is in milliseconds, and Screenshotly only waits for network idle when you set waitForNetworkIdle.
Sources
ScreenshotOne details were checked on . Vendors change prices and features, so confirm current terms on their sites.
Ready to switch to Screenshotly?
Every account includes 100 free captures. Paid plans start at $14 a month.
Related Reading
Other Comparisons
vs Self-Hosted Puppeteer
Compare a managed screenshot API with running Puppeteer or Playwright on your own infrastructure. The trade-off is browser control and network access against the work of operating headless Chrome.
vs Browser Extensions
Browser extensions are fine for one-off captures. A screenshot API is what you reach for once captures need to run from code, on a schedule, or inside CI.
vs Urlbox
Compare Screenshotly and Urlbox on list price, how usage is counted, compliance posture, and capture features, so you can see which fits your workload.